4.5 Despite bad comments, i loved it. FayeSimone | 03/08/2011 | See all FayeSimone's reviews (5) As a huge twilight fan i was skeptical of this book as i heard so many bad comments from friends and colleagues who are also obsessed with the saga,And as i had expected i still loved it and found it totally gripping it made me laugh, it made me cry and i really could not put it down. I was eager to get to the end so that i knew what happened but once i finished it i was disapointed that it was over.If i have to give a fall it was the 'fight' at the between the Voltori and the Cullens as there was such a build up and then it dilated into nothing. I would of prefered abit more fighting.Other than that fantastic book!Based on my experience read the book before you judge it. It will suprise you!