Quite frankly I'm not a big big fan of either twilight movie, Bought this for the missus (a likley story I'm sure your thinkin') As she is a major R-patz fan and Twihard (she is also a Gleek but that has nothing to do with Twilight just thought It'd be fun to mention it as I have reffered to her by her "fan" names) Anyway, didn't much like Twilight but can say that New Moon in my opion is a better movie, more fun, light hearted, good little moments but it certainly ain't a classic...
The Blu-ray presentation is whats key in this review... The image qaulity, sound and extras are all top notch and are perfect examples of the format and why it is better than DVD... If you have the option buy the movie on Blu-ray and you won't be dissapointed...as for the film it really does depend on your tatse... I enjoyed it but wouldn't rank it high....