Nothing has been the same in the little town of Long Bay, Ontario since Chris Cutter (Paul Gross) disappeared ten years ago. When curling star Cutter took off, he didn't just throw away a chance to win the Golden Broom, he actually hurled the curling stones into the waters of Trout Lake!

His three team-mates did not fare too well. Neil Bucyk (James Allodi) is a dissatisfied mortician in a marriage as lifeless as his customers; James Lennox (Peter Outerbridge) is constantly courting trouble, and this time he's headed for a date with a thug who's tracking him down in search of payback; and Eddie Strombeck (Jed Rees) can't impregnate his wife because of his single digit sperm count! Returning to the town for a funeral, the codecil stipulates that Cutter should re-form the Long Bay Curling Club and win the Golden Broom. Cutter calls in his eccentric father Gordon (Leslie Nielsen) and thus, these four men with brooms, together with their coach embark on a comedic journey that takes them from frozen lakes to huge arenas, searching for perfect stones, lost loves and second chances!