Halo 3 is a great game all round with great weapons, great scenery and great AI although the flood still manages to annoy everyone. The limited edition tin case is a bad idea, they are pretty weak and break easily. Apart from that flaw this game is a must have.

Halo is the best game in the world. It has the best gameplay, you have to get xbox live if you get this game. Halo on live is just to good, Could play it for 10000 years and wouldnt get bored!. Just a great game overall. 10/10. =]

...seriously, do not buy this game! I was really expecting this game to be EPIC but it just let me down! Lucky I also have a PS3 to play decent games on!!

It's a great game, & would get 5 stars from me, but BOTH of my discs cracked in the centre from the dodgy disc-holders in the box & the game therefore wouldn't play after only a few months. One of the disc-holders was detached so the disc also slides around in the box. Microsoft disc replacement programme has now replaced both for free, but did try to get payment for replacements first. I would avoid this edition & go for the standard one, or get this, but keep your discs in different packaging. Frankly, this edition should have been withdrawn until new packaging was produced.

Dont bother with this version, buy the normal Halo 3 version.
Anyway my ratings...

Graphics - 9/10
Storyline - 9/10
Gameplay - 9/10
Sound - 10/10
A.I - 9.5/10
Xbox Live - 9.5/10

Overall 9/10 (Legend Game but Gears Of War is taking over so i Recommend Halo 3 and Gears Of War 2 as they are the best games for the Xbox 360!!!)

These limited edition cases are terrible. In addition to scratching the DVDs, they can also cause your game DVDs to crack like mine recently did (I'm currently trying to get a replacement). The spindle in the case is also held on with some glue that doesn't do a very good job and fails after a month or two.

This is just a case review, the game itself is fantastic. I recommend buying the game with the regular DVD case.

The game itself is amazing and you'll never get bored of it. However it could be better! But if you want to buy halo 3 then DO NOT buy this version! The disk falls out all the time and if you keep removing and putting the disk back in repeatedly the disk will eventually crack and/or snap! The only things you get with this are an extra book and a crappy DVD. Nothing special, buy the normal edition!

This is my favourite game so far!

The story is a little slack but the online multiplayer has been perfected once again! If you've played halo, and halo 2 online, this game is the one!

Ive enjoyed every second of playing the game and truely think it is the best game out for the 360 so far xD

The campaign = :-/
Legandary doesnt feel like legandary any more
The scarbs are weak shoot them in the knees a copule of time and they will invite you in for tea!

But online its a toatly diferent, with the heroic map packs now free and the legandary map pack on its way its never being a better time to play halo 3 online. Get this game if you like Fsp's that can go any way, not like cod4 where if your shoot your dead any there was nothing you could do about it.

Don't get me wrong, this is by far the best Xbox 360 game to date (and probably will be for some time), but the collectors tin is not a good investment. The extra CD is good, with free gamerpics & themes and 'making of' videos' but the tin it-self is flimsy and dosnt protect the CD's at all. When mine arrived, the bonus disc was rattling around in the case and had scratches on it. The tin was dented on the other side and the game disc isnt held in place properly.
All in all, an epic game, but just get the economy case and borrow you friends bonus disc. ;-)