I bought this game with some trepidation after reading lots of internet reviews. And after some considerable play, it leaves me feeling divided.
On the one side, the concept is very bold of Atari. It's not so much an action adventure game, and more like you are playing a part in a story. The atmosphere, set scenes, and some of the controls work really well. On the other hand ...
The Wii version has turned out something of a graphical disaster, looking more like a PS2 game than it's 360 counterpart. And in parts, the gameplay just doesn't hold up being both messy and / or buggy.
If you're into Alone In The Dark, you might enjoy this, I did, and was glad I gave it a try. But it won't be to everyone's taste, and may end up as a trade in sooner than you'd hope.