Love this game; amazing graphics (notibly when the ball hits the back of the net.. so realistic) and generally great gameplay and probably the best football game out there.
However, it still carries a few of the hated flaws that ruin the reality-experience. My most hated one is that the ref frequently gives fouls (and sometimes yellow cards) for perfectly good clean tackles from the front. Others such as unrealistically poor first touches and lack of intelligence of defenders are still apparent. However, the goalkeeper bugs seem to have been fixed and can now be relied on.
I love the speed gauge on passes, rather than it being auto'ed to reach a player makes it more realistic as you can over/under hit them and is more satisfying when you perfectly time a through ball.
Great game; just hope the next one solves some of the above.