Good game but still has some of rockstars flaws.
Let's get one thing straight this is a really good game I mean it's about time there was a decent western game out there. Rockstar have made a gem of a western but I can understand where people come from when they say it gets boring I mean you may have to get from one side of the map to another and although it's nice to get on a horse and take in the scenery it can be a little tiresome. Personally I don't think much to the character designs or animation as I think all rockstar characters are pretty dire. Where characters don't live up to much the same can't be said for the horses, they are stunning as is the scenery. So overall this game essentially GTA on horseback but at a slower pace. For the few little niggles I have encountered I still have found it a better game than GTA4. Well worth it, it needs to be in your collection.