In This Light And On This Evening

Artist: Editors

   (17 customer reviews)  | Write a review

Customer Reviews

"Average rating (17 reviews)"

Results 1-10 of 17

 Editors - but better!

| | See all traffordcat's reviews (9)

I cannot understand why people are saying you may not like this if you are a fan of their 'old stuff'
This IS clearly classic Editors, albeit a little more electronic based - they were hardly a guitar driven metal band from the start!
Every track is a winner for me, and this may even be my favourite Editors album to date!

 Somebody buy them a guitar!

| | See all AbadeoAckaleo's reviews (14)

If you're a fan of the Editor's first two albums you're going to be bitterly disappointed.
They've gone way too techno and completely lost their stylish, catchy, upbeat guitar based songs!
On neutral grounds the album isn't too bad hence the three stars but if I were going on previous records this is their worst by far.
Papillon and You Don't Know Love are the two best songs on the album but the rest are just all a bit melodramatic and too techno based.
If you've never heard of the Editors before I suggest you check out their two previous albums...
Overall 'In This Light And On This Evening' is creditable but lacking that Editor charm.
Bring back the guitars for the 4th one lads!

 fantastic cd!

| | See all dazzanewm's reviews (2)

i first listened to the cd and thought that it was a major let down (it was far too different for my liking) but i just kept listening to it and started to love it. i now cant get enough of this amazing album and cant wait to see them live :)

 majorly disappointed !!

| | See all cornerhouse's reviews (3)

Being a fan of The Editors i awaited their new release with anticipation - disappointed or what - where has all the guitar work gone - replaced with synthesisers - not a patch on previous albums - down load papilon - avoid the album !!

 Different to previous,but excellent as usual

| | See all Toadfrog25's reviews (3)

I haven't even finished playing it yet and with the headphones on is brilliant!,Shame its not longer.
A very good side step even if its very 80's
Recommend fully
Richard

 Pure Class

| | See all southcoastden's reviews (1)

If you haven't got this album then your collection is seriously lacking. This album is pure class and I remain totally amazed that the Editors tend to be ignored by the media and radio stations. Yes, there is a clear change of direction with the introduction of the synth but this does not change the definitive style and sound that the Editors ooze. Papillon is possibly the best track and could become an 'anthem'. A five star album that rightly deserved to go straight to number 1 in the album charts.

 Fantastic

| | See all ProfJohn's reviews (1)

This is the first Editors album I've listened to after hearing on Spotify and it's fantastic. Dark and atmospheric in parts whilst uplifting in others. The overall sound is reminiscent of Interpol. A very good album, well worth it.

 Editors-in this light and on this evening

| | See all enterthemackem's reviews (9)

To change your style of music so drastically is always a risk but it's paid off.A great album that get's better and better with every play.