Having never heard a Nightwish album before I didn't have the apprehension that existing fans would given that this is the first album without Tarja. But I don't think I would have anything to worry about as this is simply amazing. I am a long time fan of the brilliant Within Temptation and had been recommended Nightwish and they certainly don't disappoint. Annette's vocals are, IMO superb and are perfectly suited to Nightwish's metal/orchestral music.
The opening track ,The Poet And The Pendulum, is an epic 14 minutes long and to me is the best. It has everything.... metal, Riverdance style music, amazing orchestral/choir and endings with a moving melodic theme. Truly stunning. However I can honestly say I love every track (ok, possibly not Whoever Brings The Night) and the whole album amazingly improves with every listening.
I will never tire of this album!